feat(consult): career answers don't guess the field — strength/resistance/timing + one ask; follow-up reads a stated job (BUG-1176 decision); goldens regenerated; rubric round-4 pass lines; backtest script career follow-up

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01N4f2nya58RoRu4yEmJgRGE

frontend/tests/consult-affliction-reading-20261001.test.ts

@@ -129,13 +129,9 @@ test("T3: career, marriage and wealth each carry their affliction line", () => {
   assert.ok(CONSULTATION_CONDENSED_CHECKLISTS.marriage!.some((line) => line.includes("感情这条线上有波折的迹象") && line.includes("不断定有几段") && line.includes("不预设用户现在有伴侣或单身")));
   assert.ok(!CONSULTATION_CONDENSED_CHECKLISTS.marriage!.join("\n").includes("可能不止一段"));
   assert.ok(CONSULTATION_CONDENSED_CHECKLISTS.wealth!.some((line) => line.startsWith("8 宫也管版税、继承、意外之财")));
-  // 原值: career / marriage / wealth 都是 5–8 行
-  // 新值: marriage / wealth 仍 5–8 行；career 5–9 行
-  // 原因: TASK-consult-career-yoga-functional-20261002 T4 定稿给事业清单加两行（行业、公众 / 幕后的依据，BUG-1176），定稿文本不得改意思
   for (const domain of ["career", "marriage", "wealth"] as const) {
     const lines = CONSULTATION_CONDENSED_CHECKLISTS[domain]!;
-    const max = domain === "career" ? 9 : 8;
-    assert.ok(lines.length >= 5 && lines.length <= max, domain);
+    assert.ok(lines.length >= 5 && lines.length <= 8, domain);
   }
 });
 

frontend/tests/consult-career-yoga-functional-20261002.test.ts

@@ -19,7 +19,12 @@ import {
   CONDENSED_SHARED_READING_LINES,
   CONSULTATION_CONDENSED_CHECKLISTS,
 } from "../src/lib/consultation-condensed-checklist.ts";
-import { natalAnswerShapeBody } from "../src/lib/consultation-thinking-plan.ts";
+import {
+  CAREER_FIELD_ASK_RULE,
+  CAREER_FOLLOW_UP_RULE,
+  followUpAnswerShapeInstruction,
+  natalAnswerShapeBody,
+} from "../src/lib/consultation-thinking-plan.ts";
 import {
   consultationWorkflowResponseSchema,
   toAgentConsultationContext,
@@ -79,10 +84,27 @@ test("shared reading: traditional yogas only show strength", () => {
   assert.ok(CONDENSED_SHARED_READING_LINES.includes("`traditional_yogas` 只用来说明力量，不单独下结论，不算受冲，也不抵消受冲。"));
 });
 
-test("career list: field by planet nature, public only with chart evidence (T4 text)", () => {
+test("career: no field / public verdict, ask what the user does (product decision 2026-10-02)", () => {
   const career = CONSULTATION_CONDENSED_CHECKLISTS.career!;
-  assert.ok(career.includes("行业看星的本性：10 宫里的星、10 宫主、AmK，以及 10 宫主在 D9 的定位星。太阳 = 权力、公职、管理；月亮 = 公众、照护、流动；火星 = 体力、竞技、工程、军警；水星 = 沟通、写作、商业、分析；木星 = 教育、法律、顾问、宗教；金星 = 艺术、表演、娱乐、美；土星 = 劳动、组织、长期工程；罗睺 = 新技术、跨界、海外、大众传播。先说最强的一两颗，不平均罗列。"));
-  assert.ok(career.includes("公众型还是幕后型要有依据：太阳或 10 宫主强且在角宫、AL 或 A10 落角宫、10 宫或命宫有入旺入庙星、`traditional_yogas` 有大格局，偏公众；10 宫主落 12 宫且无上述信号，才偏幕后。没有依据就不写这一句。不写「出头慢、越往后越稳、靠专业交付」这类人人适用的话，除非能指出具体盘面。"));
+  assert.equal(career[0], CAREER_FIELD_ASK_RULE);
+  assert.equal(CONSULTATION_CONDENSED_CHECKLISTS.career!.filter((line) => line === CAREER_FIELD_ASK_RULE).length, 1);
+  for (const phrase of ["不替用户断定他做哪一行、是公众型还是幕后型", "「出头慢」「越往后越稳」「靠专业交付」", "事业这一段末尾用一句话问用户实际做什么", "这一句就是全篇唯一一处请用户说实际情况"]) {
+    assert.ok(CAREER_FIELD_ASK_RULE.includes(phrase), phrase);
+  }
+  const text = career.join("\n");
+  assert.doesNotMatch(text, /行业看星的本性|公众型还是幕后型要有依据|公众形象就是事业/);
+  // The rule is defined once (thinking plan) and only quoted by the career list.
+  const plan = readFileSync(new URL("../src/lib/consultation-thinking-plan.ts", import.meta.url), "utf8");
+  const list = readFileSync(new URL("../src/lib/consultation-condensed-checklist.ts", import.meta.url), "utf8");
+  assert.ok(plan.includes("export const CAREER_FIELD_ASK_RULE = "));
+  assert.equal(list.includes("不替用户断定他做哪一行"), false);
+});
+
+test("follow-up: a stated job is read against the chart, nothing invented", () => {
+  const followUp = followUpAnswerShapeInstruction();
+  assert.ok(followUp.includes(CAREER_FOLLOW_UP_RULE));
+  assert.match(CAREER_FOLLOW_UP_RULE, /按这份工作去读盘上的力量、阻力和时间/);
+  assert.match(CAREER_FOLLOW_UP_RULE, /不为它编盘上没有的依据/);
 });
 
 test("opener keeps the affliction rule (T5 text)", () => {

frontend/tests/consult-condensed-checklist-20260927.test.ts

@@ -79,16 +79,12 @@ test("each condensed list is 5–8 lines", () => {
   // 原值：全部清单 5–8 行，且只有 career / marriage / wealth 三份；
   // 新值：这三份仍 5–8 行；另有 TASK-consult-affliction-reading-20261001 定稿的 8 份（2–6 行，按任务书原文，不凑行数），
   // 只有 timing 没有本地清单；原因：该任务书 T2 / 决策 D5 补齐清单，定稿文本不得改意思。
-  // 原值：career / marriage / wealth 5–8 行；新值：marriage / wealth 5–8 行、career 5–9 行；
-  // 原因：TASK-consult-career-yoga-functional-20261002 T4 定稿给事业清单加两行（BUG-1176），定稿文本不凑行数。
   for (const domain of ["career", "marriage", "wealth"] as const) {
     const lines = CONSULTATION_CONDENSED_CHECKLISTS[domain]!;
-    const max = domain === "career" ? 9 : 8;
-    assert.ok(lines.length >= 5 && lines.length <= max, `${domain}: ${lines.length} lines`);
+    assert.ok(lines.length >= 5 && lines.length <= 8, `${domain}: ${lines.length} lines`);
   }
   for (const [domain, lines] of Object.entries(CONSULTATION_CONDENSED_CHECKLISTS)) {
-    const max = domain === "career" ? 9 : 8;
-    assert.ok(lines!.length >= 2 && lines!.length <= max, `${domain}: ${lines!.length} lines`);
+    assert.ok(lines!.length >= 2 && lines!.length <= 8, `${domain}: ${lines!.length} lines`);
   }
   assert.deepEqual(Object.keys(CONSULTATION_CONDENSED_CHECKLISTS).sort(), [
     "annual", "career", "children", "education", "family", "general", "health", "marriage", "migration", "parents", "wealth",
@@ -100,7 +96,10 @@ test("the writer's prompt carries the condensed list with the three layers and t
     // 原值: career: ["接触", "结构性机会", "公开落地", …]
     // 新值: 三层改为「机会出现 / 成形 / 公开落地」，加「事业形态」行；不得再有「面试」「职位」
     // 原因: 产品 2026-10-02 改口径（名人回测对照组误报 1→15；盘分不出父母在不在、几段感情、有没有病）；第 3 层的「面试 / 正式职位」把读者设成求职者（BUG-1168）
-    career: ["接触", "机会出现", "成形", "公开落地", "事业形态", "事业必成", "d9 段", "KP 精确宫头仍 blocked"],
+    // 原值(2): career 必含「事业形态」
+    // 新值(2): 改为必含「不替用户断定他做哪一行」（CAREER_FIELD_ASK_RULE）
+    // 原因(2): 产品 2026-10-02「行业不猜，问用户」，删掉「先讲一生事业形态：公众型还是幕后型」（BUG-1176）
+    career: ["接触", "机会出现", "成形", "公开落地", "不替用户断定他做哪一行", "事业必成", "d9 段", "KP 精确宫头仍 blocked"],
     marriage: [
       "心动接触", "关系成对", "社会法律落地",
       "5 宫主大运 ≠ 法律婚", "金星过本命月亮 ≠ 心动月", "Punarphoo 不得写成结婚", "土星回到本命月亮是观察项，不是结婚",

frontend/tests/consult-no-presupposition-20261001.test.ts

@@ -109,8 +109,11 @@ test("2026-10-02: the shared reading quotes the range rule; parents, marriage, h
   assert.match(health, /身体这条线有压力的迹象/);
   assert.match(health, /不写「底子不差」/);
   const career = CONSULTATION_CONDENSED_CHECKLISTS.career!;
-  assert.ok(career[0]!.startsWith("先讲这张盘一生的事业形态：公众型还是幕后型"));
-  assert.match(career.join("\n"), /受冲只说阻力和代价，不改写事业形态/);
+  // 原值: career[0] 以「先讲这张盘一生的事业形态：公众型还是幕后型」开头；含「受冲只说阻力和代价，不改写事业形态」
+  // 新值: career[0] 是 CAREER_FIELD_ASK_RULE（只讲力量、阻力、时间；不断定行业与公众 / 幕后；段末问一句实际做什么）
+  // 原因: 产品 2026-10-02 决定「行业不猜，问用户」（TASK-consult-career-yoga-functional-20261002，BUG-1176；第三轮回测行业对 3/18）
+  assert.ok(career[0]!.startsWith("事业题只讲盘上的力量、阻力和时间"));
+  assert.match(career.join("\n"), /不替用户断定他做哪一行、是公众型还是幕后型/);
   assert.doesNotMatch(career.join("\n"), /面试|职位|简历/);
   // The shape and the voice example carry no presence verdict.
   assert.doesNotMatch(productConversationVoice, /他可能不常在你身边，或者有一段时间不在|如果实际情况不是这样/);