From 707065a0bc63dcd5dd8d84771f341baa4236a772 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: 732642856 <732642856@qq.com> Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 13:41:17 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] Clean technique registry warnings - Add limitation fields to all 14 partial techniques - Fix 7 knowledge_refs paths (add missing references/ prefix) - Create placeholder references: bphs-ch48-narayana-dasha.md, muhurta-complete-guide.md - audit: valid=true, problem_count=0, warning_count=0 --- references/bphs-ch48-narayana-dasha.md | 33 +++++++++++++++ references/muhurta-complete-guide.md | 51 +++++++++++++++++++++++ references/technique_registry.json | 56 ++++++++++++++++---------- 3 files changed, 119 insertions(+), 21 deletions(-) create mode 100644 references/bphs-ch48-narayana-dasha.md create mode 100644 references/muhurta-complete-guide.md diff --git a/references/bphs-ch48-narayana-dasha.md b/references/bphs-ch48-narayana-dasha.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..10d020b8 --- /dev/null +++ b/references/bphs-ch48-narayana-dasha.md @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +# BPHS Chapter 48 – Narayana Dasha + +## 概述 + +Narayana Dasha（亦作 Rishi Dasha / Padakrama Dasha）是 Parasara 体系中的另一种大运系统， +以 Lagna 为起点，按黄道十二星座顺序推进，每个星座的大运长度取决于该星座的守护星 +到该星座的"步数"。 + +## 计算方法（PVN Rao / BPHS Ch.48 传统算法） + +1. 从 Lagna 所在星座开始 +2. 按黄道顺序（白羊→金牛→双子→...→双鱼）遍历 12 星座 +3. 每个星座的大运年数 = 该星座守护星所在星座到该星座的"步数" + - 例如：Lagna 在白羊，白羊守护星 Mars 在巨蟹 = 4 步 → 白羊大运 4 年 + +## 当前实现状态 + +当前 `scripts/narayana_dasha.py` 实现了基础算法，覆盖： +- Lagna 起运 +- 黄道序 12 星座推进 +- 守护星步数计算 + +## 局限 + +- 未完整覆盖 BPHS Ch.48 所有变体 +- 未与 PyJHora Narayana Dasha 做基准比对 +- 当前标注为 **covered**，待 benchmark 后确认 + +## 参考 + +- BPHS Chapter 48 (Rao 英译) +- PyJHora Narayana Dasha 输出 +- PVN Rao "Dasa Systems in Hindu Astrology" diff --git a/references/muhurta-complete-guide.md b/references/muhurta-complete-guide.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..4a6fef18 --- /dev/null +++ b/references/muhurta-complete-guide.md @@ -0,0 +1,51 @@ +# Muhurta Complete Guide + +## 概述 + +Muhurta 是 Vedic 择时占星系统，核心目标是在正确的时间启动行动， +使事件结果最大化。Muhurta 分析基于 Panchanga 五要素。 + +## Panchanga 五要素 + +| 要素 | 含义 | +|---|---| +| Tithi | 月相日（月亮相对于太阳的角度，1-15） | +| Vara | 曜日（周日=太阳，周一=月亮，...） | +| Nakshatra | 月亮所在星宿（27 宿） | +| Yoga | 日月合相特殊组合（27 种） | +| Karana | 半 Tithi（11 种） | + +## 其他要素 + +- **Hora**：昼/夜由太阳/土星守护的时段 +- **Abhijit**：中天最吉时刻（非所有日都存在） + +## 活动适宜性判断 + +核心原则： +1. Rasi / Nakshatra 与活动性质的匹配 +2. 避开 Kemadruma / Rikta Tithi +3. 检查 Vara / Hora 守护星强度 +4. 避开恶性 Yoga（如 Vaidhriti） + +## 当前实现状态 + +`scripts/muhurta.py` v6.0.21 实现： +- Panchanga 五要素计算 +- Hora / Abhijit 计算 +- 5 类活动适宜性检查 +- `--scan-days` 多日扫描 + +## 局限 + +- 未覆盖所有 20+ 传统活动类型 +- 部分禁忌规则简化 +- 未与经典 Muhurta 表（如 Muhurta Chintamani）做完整 benchmark + +当前标注：**covered**，待更多活动类型补充后升级。 + +## 参考 + +- "Muhurta Chintamani" (Sage Narada) +- "Essentials of Muhurta" (Sanjay Rath) +- PyJHora Muhurta 模块 diff --git a/references/technique_registry.json b/references/technique_registry.json index ccc11e35..07033c99 100644 --- a/references/technique_registry.json +++ b/references/technique_registry.json @@ -416,7 +416,8 @@ "modules.tajika_yogas" ], "audit_label": "Tajika Yogas", - "missing_impact": "Tajika year-chart yoga detection incomplete; annual timing confidence capped." + "missing_impact": "Tajika year-chart yoga detection incomplete; annual timing confidence capped.", + "limitation": "当前 Tajika Yoga 检测基于简化规则（如 Itasala、Ishkavala 等），未完整覆盖 PyJHora 的 10 种年度瑜伽分类和 Vedha 阻碍逻辑。年运盘格局判断只能作为辅助参考，不宜作为高置信度应期主证据。" }, "sahams": { "name": "Sahams / 特殊点", @@ -435,7 +436,8 @@ "modules.sahams" ], "audit_label": "Sahams", - "missing_impact": "Saham point calculation incomplete; annual/event timing layer missing." + "missing_impact": "Saham point calculation incomplete; annual/event timing layer missing.", + "limitation": "Saham 特殊点计算当前仅支持部分常用点，未完整覆盖 36 种传统 Saham。计算精度与 Tajika 系统对齐度未经验证，不宜作为精确事件定位依据。" }, "darakaraka": { "name": "Darakaraka (DK) / 配偶星", @@ -472,7 +474,8 @@ "modules.yogas_doshas.raj_yogas" ], "audit_label": "Raj Yoga", - "missing_impact": "Power/status timing confidence capped without Raj Yoga detection." + "missing_impact": "Power/status timing confidence capped without Raj Yoga detection.", + "limitation": "Raj Yoga 检测基于经典组合规则，但未完整覆盖 BV Raman 186 种额外瑜伽分类和 PyJHora 的 284 种瑜伽体系。部分复杂组合（如 Viparita Raja Yoga 的变体）可能漏检。只能作为权力/地位潜力的辅助参考。" }, "dhana_yoga": { "name": "Dhana Yoga / 财富瑜伽", @@ -490,7 +493,8 @@ "modules.yogas_doshas.dhana_yogas" ], "audit_label": "Dhana Yoga", - "missing_impact": "Wealth timing confidence capped without Dhana Yoga." + "missing_impact": "Wealth timing confidence capped without Dhana Yoga.", + "limitation": "Dhana Yoga 检测覆盖经典财富组合，但未完整实现所有变体（如特定分盘中的 Dhana Yoga、Dhana Yoga 与 Raja Yoga 的复合情况）。财富潜力评估应结合 D2、D9、D10 分盘综合分析，不宜仅凭 Yoga 检测做绝对断言。" }, "pancha_mahapurusha": { "name": "Pancha Mahapurusha Yoga / 五王瑜伽", @@ -508,7 +512,8 @@ "modules.yogas_doshas.pancha_mahapurusha" ], "audit_label": "Pancha Mahapurusha", - "missing_impact": "Personality strength assessment incomplete." + "missing_impact": "Personality strength assessment incomplete.", + "limitation": "五王瑜伽（Ruchaka、Bhadra 等）检测基于基础规则，但未完整覆盖所有变体条件（如燃烧、逆行、受克时的 Yoga 失效条件）。与 PyJHora 的 284 种瑜伽体系对齐度未经验证。只能作为人格特质的辅助参考。" }, "nicha_bhanga_raj": { "name": "Neecha Bhanga Raj Yoga / 落陷解除王者瑜伽", @@ -526,7 +531,8 @@ "modules.yogas_doshas.nicha_bhanga_raj" ], "audit_label": "Neecha Bhanga", - "missing_impact": "Debilitation recovery analysis incomplete." + "missing_impact": "Debilitation recovery analysis incomplete.", + "limitation": "Neecha Bhanga Raja Yoga 检测覆盖经典落陷解除条件，但未完整覆盖所有变体（如多重落陷解除、分盘中的 Neecha Bhanga 条件）。落陷解除后的力量恢复程度未做精细量化，不宜作为绝对断言依据。" }, "mangal_dosha": { "name": "Mangal Dosha / 火星煞", @@ -598,7 +604,8 @@ "modules.yogas_doshas.sade_sati" ], "audit_label": "Sade Sati", - "missing_impact": "Saturn pressure timing incomplete." + "missing_impact": "Saturn pressure timing incomplete.", + "limitation": "Sade Sati 当前按土星经过月亮前后星座的简化模型计算，未完整覆盖全部影响条件（如土星在 Kendra 时的强度变化、Ashtakavarga 对 Sade Sati 的修正、Kantaka Shani 细分阶段）。压力程度评估为近似值，不宜作为精确事件预测依据。" }, "arudha_lagna": { "name": "Arudha Lagna (AL) / 镜像上升", @@ -653,7 +660,8 @@ "modules.tithi_lord" ], "audit_label": "Tithi Lord", - "missing_impact": "Tithi Lord 分析不完整，Prashna 问卜时机判断受限。" + "missing_impact": "Tithi Lord 分析不完整，Prashna 问卜时机判断受限。", + "limitation": "Tithi Lord 计算基于 Tithi 度数划分规则，但当前实现未完整覆盖所有 Tithi 类型（如 Kshaya Tithi、Adhika Tithi）的特殊处理。与 Prashna 系统的深度整合仍在 partial 状态，问卜时机判断应结合 Nakshatra、Vara 等多要素综合分析。" }, "pancha_pakshi": { "name": "Pancha Pakshi / 五鸟系统", @@ -672,7 +680,8 @@ "modules.pancha_pakshi" ], "audit_label": "Pancha Pakshi", - "missing_impact": "五鸟系统分析不完整，Tamil 占星时机判断受限。" + "missing_impact": "五鸟系统分析不完整，Tamil 占星时机判断受限。", + "limitation": "Pancha Pakshi 当前实现基于简化规则，未完整覆盖传统五鸟系统的全部活动类型（如行走、飞翔、进食、睡眠、死亡）与 Nakshatra 的精细对应关系。与 Tamil 占星传统中的完整五鸟法对齐度未经验证，不宜作为精确择时依据。" }, "rashi_tulya_navamsa": { "name": "Rashi Tulya Navamsa / 本命对分盘分析", @@ -691,7 +700,8 @@ "modules.rashi_tulya_navamsa" ], "audit_label": "Rashi Tulya Navamsa", - "missing_impact": "D1-D9 同宫对比分析不完整，婚姻/内在潜力判断受限。" + "missing_impact": "D1-D9 同宫对比分析不完整，婚姻/内在潜力判断受限。", + "limitation": "Rashi Tulya Navamsa 分析当前基于 D1 与 D9 同宫行星的简单对比，未完整覆盖所有变体条件（如行星在 D9 中的精确度数对比、Vargottama 与非 Vargottama 的混合情况）。婚姻和内在潜力的深度解读应结合更多分盘（D7、D12）交叉验证。" }, "marriage_counting": { "name": "Marriage Counting Method / 婚姻计数法", @@ -703,7 +713,7 @@ ], "status": "partial", "knowledge_refs": [ - "bhrigu-pada-dasha-marriage-counting.md" + "references/bhrigu-pada-dasha-marriage-counting.md" ], "commands": [ "full-reading" @@ -712,7 +722,8 @@ "modules.marriage_counting" ], "audit_label": "Marriage Counting", - "missing_impact": "婚姻数量判断不完整，关系模式分析受限。" + "missing_impact": "婚姻数量判断不完整，关系模式分析受限。", + "limitation": "当前实现使用 Bhrigu Pada 近似算法，未进行 Nakshatra-level 精细计数。与经典 Bhrigu 表格 benchmark 未完成。可作为婚姻时机辅助参考，不作为精确计数依据。" }, "trimshamsa_d30": { "name": "Trimshamsa D30 / 三十分盘", @@ -724,7 +735,7 @@ ], "status": "partial", "knowledge_refs": [ - "varga-system-quick-reference.md" + "references/varga-system-quick-reference.md" ], "commands": [ "full-reading" @@ -733,7 +744,8 @@ "modules.trimshamsa_d30" ], "audit_label": "D30 Trimshamsa", - "missing_impact": "D30 灾难分析不完整，危机事件判断受限。" + "missing_impact": "D30 灾难分析不完整，危机事件判断受限。", + "limitation": "D30 分盘计算已实现，但 Trimshamsa 的灾难/突发事件解读规则未完整覆盖经典文献。当前输出可作为辅助参考，不作为精确灾难预测依据。" }, "muntha": { "name": "Muntha / 年运之主 (Tajika)", @@ -745,7 +757,7 @@ ], "status": "covered", "knowledge_refs": [ - "tajika-yoga-complete-guide.md" + "references/tajika-yoga-complete-guide.md" ], "commands": [ "full-reading" @@ -766,7 +778,7 @@ ], "status": "covered", "knowledge_refs": [ - "tajika-yoga-complete-guide.md" + "references/tajika-yoga-complete-guide.md" ], "commands": [ "solar-return", @@ -796,7 +808,8 @@ "modules.prashna" ], "audit_label": "Prashna Integration", - "missing_impact": "Prashna 未接入 full-reading，问事分析不完整。" + "missing_impact": "Prashna 未接入 full-reading，问事分析不完整。", + "limitation": "Prashna 当前为 partial 状态，独立命令可用但尚未与 full-reading 严格路由完全整合。问事盘（horary chart）与出生盘（natal chart）的区分逻辑尚未完全清晰，Prashna 特殊规则（如 Lagna 动/静判断、Karya Hora 等）覆盖不完整。问事分析不宜与出生盘解读混用。" }, "bhrigu_pada_dasha": { "name": "Bhrigu Pada Dasha / 足步推进法", @@ -808,7 +821,7 @@ ], "status": "partial", "knowledge_refs": [ - "bhrigu-pada-dasha-marriage-counting.md" + "references/bhrigu-pada-dasha-marriage-counting.md" ], "commands": [ "full-reading" @@ -817,7 +830,8 @@ "modules.bhrigu_pada_dasha" ], "audit_label": "Bhrigu Pada Dasha", - "missing_impact": "Bhrigu 足步推进法缺失，婚姻时机精确预测受限（通用近似版已实现）。" + "missing_impact": "Bhrigu 足步推进法缺失，婚姻时机精确预测受限（通用近似版已实现）。", + "limitation": "Bhrigu Pada Dasha 当前实现为通用近似版本，未完整对齐传统 Bhrigu 系统的精细步进规则（如 Nakshatra-level 计数、特定条件下的步数修正）。与经典 Bhrigu 表格和 PyJHora 对应模块的 benchmark 未完成。婚姻时机预测应结合 Vimshottari Dasha 和 Transit 多要素交叉验证。" }, "narayana_dasha": { "name": "Narayana Dasha (Rishi Dasha / Padakrama Dasha)", @@ -829,7 +843,7 @@ ], "status": "covered", "knowledge_refs": [ - "bphs-ch48-narayana-dasha.md" + "references/bphs-ch48-narayana-dasha.md" ], "commands": [ "narayana-dasha", @@ -855,7 +869,7 @@ ], "status": "covered", "knowledge_refs": [ - "muhurta-complete-guide.md" + "references/muhurta-complete-guide.md" ], "commands": [ "muhurta"