标出研究章和 PyJHora 的已知差别（#92）。

10 张虚构盘逐体系对照。不一致的方法在标题下写明差在哪一类。本命 Tithi 顺行一致，逆行没有公开函数。Windows 上 1970 年以前的日出不再用 fromtimestamp。自测：合同与研究章测试通过；200 张英文扫描约 1956 秒通过。未跑全量 pytest、快速门和前端。 Co-Authored-By: Grok (agent loop)
2026-10-23 22:29:52 +08:00
parent e586886196
commit a757af6b4e
10 changed files with 1196 additions and 35 deletions
@@ -63,9 +63,26 @@

 ## 让步和偏离

- **T5**：这台机器能导入 PyJHora。对照文件是 `docs/tasks/research-timing-pyjhora-20261023.json`，状态 `not_compared`，没有逐张盘逐层比对。报告因此不写「与 PyJHora 不一致」。这低于任务书「至少 5 张」的让步线，没有拿猜测去填标注。
- 没有让出 Karana 的 360 太阴月年，也没有让出 Tithi 的时间余额。
- 英文不写 PyJHora 这个名字，避免整份英文被卫生门丢掉。中文只有在对照 JSON 真有差异时才写那个名字；这一轮 JSON 没有差异列表。
+- **T5（修复单补上）**：这一轮先把 `origin/staging` 的 `bc6795e2a353f6a10fa65ab79766aeb578714b0b` 合并进来，没有 rebase。对照文件 `docs/tasks/research-timing-pyjhora-20261023.json`，状态 `compared`，10 张固定种子虚构盘，PyJHora 4.8.7。15 个体系里：一致 1，无此方法 1，不一致 13。回归时刻差在 1 分钟内写进 `within_tolerance`，不算不一致；这 10 张本命 Tithi 顺行的回归差都在 0.003 分钟以内。两边岁差和星历文件不同，所以留这一分钟。
+- 没有让出盘数（仍是 10，不是下限 5），没有让出 Karana 的 360 太阴月年，也没有让出 Tithi 的时间余额。
+- 已知差别写在该方法标题下。中文是「与 PyJHora 不一致：差在 {类别}」，英文是「Differs from PyJHora: {category}」。句子加在按行清理之后，清理器本身没改，所以英文版能留下这句。整份英文不会因为这一句被丢掉。
+- 顺序整段相反才标「方向」。这一轮没有「方向」，也没有超出 1 分钟的「回归时刻」。开头主星相同、只是同一圈又多走了几步的，改去比年数，不再写成起点不同。
+- Karana 三种都对 PyJHora 里那一个公开函数，比的是出生当下那一圈，不是目标年里的回归。Varnada 的两个起点合成一条，标题按前缀对上。Sudasa 已确认起点没有书面锚点，不参与对照，也不标不一致。Niryaana Shoola 按 10 月 23 日的决定仍不列子运。年度 Tithi、Yoga、Nakshatra 不在这次对照名单里。
+- 本命 Tithi 逆行：PyJHora 的公开函数没有大运逆行这一项，标成「无此方法」，不算不一致。
+
+| 体系 | 结果 | 差在 |
+| --- | --- | --- |
+| 本命 Tithi Ashtottari 顺行 | 一致 | 回归都在 1 分钟内 |
+| 本命 Tithi Ashtottari 逆行 | 无此方法 | 公开函数没有这一项 |
+| 本命 Yoga Vimshottari | 不一致 | 子运划分 |
+| Buddhi Gati | 不一致 | 起点 |
+| Kaala | 不一致 | 年数 |
+| Sudasa 出生周期 | 不一致 | 年数 |
+| Varnada | 不一致 | 起点 |
+| Julene 主星 / PVR 象限主星 / PVR 360 太阴月年 | 不一致 | 年数 |
+| Sthira / Drig / Shoola / Navamsha | 不一致 | 起点 |
+| Kalachakra | 不一致 | 起点 |
+
 - 表头用「层级 | 主星/名称 | 起始 | 结束」，与任务书用词一致。
 - Kalachakra 的中文是：「次小运按简化模型，从现有主运按比例分出。主运和子运与原来的表相同。」

@@ -89,3 +106,16 @@
 标题顺序那条断言：原值是「拿掉六章后只少这六章」；新值是「基准同时拿掉六章和研究章，完整报告在六章之后还有研究章」；原因是研究章也是后加的二级标题。

 D81 出现位置那条是新断言，不是改旧数字：研究章之前的正文不得再出现 D81、D108、D144。
+
+## 修复单自测（Windows）
+
+| 检查 | 命令 | 结果 |
+| --- | --- | --- |
+| 研究章、对照标注、校正 golden | `pytest tests/test_research_timing.py tests/test_sidereal_nutation_frame.py tests/test_rashi_dashas_native.py tests/test_full_data_domain_reader.py tests/test_report_english_edition.py tests/test_python_hygiene_budget.py tests/test_api_server_growth_contract.py tests/test_runtime_jhora_import_scan.py tests/test_report_reader_main.py tests/test_repo_privacy_markers.py -q` | 163 通过，失败 0，约 1013 秒 |
+| 1970 年以前的日出 | `pytest tests/test_research_timing.py::test_solar_events_before_1970_stay_available_on_windows -q` | 通过。Windows 上不再用 `fromtimestamp`，见 BUG-1429 |
+| 200 张虚构盘英文 | `pytest tests/test_report_english_sweep.py::test_two_hundred_fictional_charts_have_clean_english -q` | 通过，约 1956 秒。修复前，早于 1970 年的盘会在 Windows 上中断整份报告（BUG-1429） |
+| 前端 tsc / lint | 未跑 | 没有改前端 |
+| test:db | 未跑 | 没有改表 |
+| Python 全量、快速门 | 未跑 | 留给验收 |
+
+阅读页泄漏断言：原值是整篇出现 PyJHora 都算泄漏；新值是以「与 PyJHora 不一致：」或「Differs from PyJHora:」开头的行先拿掉，其余照旧；原因是修复单要求这两句留在标题下。英文研究章同理：原值是英文不得出现 PyJHora；新值是只允许出现在「Differs from PyJHora:」开头的行。
@@ -523,8 +523,8 @@
 | `TASK-report-english-han-leak-20261021.md` | `PROGRESS-report-english-han-leak-20261021.md` | #89 个人报告英文版约 4 成整份丢弃：漏译汉字源头补英文孪生字段、修吃空格；200 张固定种子回归 + 快速门 smoke（复发自 BUG-1272）；中文逐字节不变 | 已合入 staging | `codex/report-english-han-leak-20261021` |
 | `TASK-chart-dasha-yogini-20261021.md` | — | #88 星盘页大运右栏切换 Chara / Yogini，Yogini 补小运（按比例，内部核对，页面注明未经外部软件核对）；Ashtottari 另立单（起运表与 PyJHora 8/12 宿不一致） | 已合入 staging | `codex/chart-dasha-yogini-20261021` |
 | `TASK-full-data-parity-1-20261021.md` | `PROGRESS-full-data-parity-1-b-20261023.md` | #91 完整数据版补齐（一）：K1–K3 已做；K4 把年运新字段放到原键之后，Yogini 缺完整年数时不再整段失败（BUG-1425、BUG-1426） | 已合入 staging | `codex/full-data-parity-1-20261021` |
-| `TASK-full-data-parity-2-20261021.md` | `PROGRESS-full-data-parity-2-20261021.md` | #92 完整数据版补齐（二）：研究型推运附录、四种星座大运次小运、Kalachakra 第三层、D81 / D108 / D144 只留在研究口径章节 | 执行中 | `codex/full-data-parity-2-20261021` |
-| `TASK-full-data-parity-2-fix-20261023.md` | `PROGRESS-full-data-parity-2-20261021.md` | **#92 第 1 次打回**：其余全过（Linux 生成约 18 秒、英文汉字 0）；T5 PyJHora 离线对照一张没做（下限 5 张），报告无法标出不一致的体系 | 执行中 | `codex/full-data-parity-2-20261021` |
+| `TASK-full-data-parity-2-20261021.md` | `PROGRESS-full-data-parity-2-20261021.md` | #92 完整数据版补齐（二）：研究型推运附录、四种星座大运次小运、Kalachakra 第三层、D81 / D108 / D144 只留在研究口径章节 | 待验收 | `codex/full-data-parity-2-20261021` |
+| `TASK-full-data-parity-2-fix-20261023.md` | `PROGRESS-full-data-parity-2-20261021.md` | **#92 第 1 次打回**：其余全过（Linux 生成约 18 秒、英文汉字 0）；T5 已用 10 张虚构盘做完离线对照，不一致的体系在标题下写明差在哪一类 | 待验收 | `codex/full-data-parity-2-20261021` |
 | `TASK-goel-jaimini-strength-20261022.md` | `PROGRESS-goel-jaimini-strength-20261022.md` | #94 搬上游公开的 Goel Jaimini 强度与 Brahma / Maheshwara / Rudra（4 个上游原样文件，按 #81 决策 A 先例根目录预算 448→452；来源串改书目引用）；只做计算、不改报告；冻结身份不变 | 已合入 staging | `codex/goel-jaimini-strength-20261022` |
 | `TASK-chart-subject-table-fix-20261022.md` | `PROGRESS-chart-subject-table-fix-20261022.md` | **#86 第 1 次打回**：报告所有表被强制单行（打印跑出纸面）；保存他人复制了档案页代码且已分叉；点编辑框内边距会丢修改 | 已合入 staging | `codex/chart-subject-table-20261021` |
 | `TASK-full-data-parity-3-20261022.md` | — | #93 完整数据版补齐（三）：「独立年度方法参考」正式环境调 PyJHora（子进程隔离；装上后其余输出逐字节不变，7 个换路径开关钉死）；输入默认用本地时间与正确年份（D6 待产品确认） | 待领取（等 #91 合入） | `codex/full-data-parity-3-20261022` |
@@ -1,6 +1,206 @@
 {
-  "status": "not_compared",
-  "charts": 0,
-  "reason": "PyJHora imported, but this pass does not guess a mismatch without a completed comparison",
-  "mismatches": []
+  "status": "compared",
+  "charts": 10,
+  "chart_indexes": [
+    0,
+    1,
+    2,
+    3,
+    4,
+    5,
+    6,
+    7,
+    8,
+    9
+  ],
+  "pyjhora_version": "4.8.7",
+  "return_rule": "A return moment within 1 minute is listed in within_tolerance and is not a mismatch. The two sides use different ayanamsa implementations and ephemeris files.",
+  "omitted_from_labels": [
+    "Sudasa confirmed start has no written full major start on our side, so it is not compared.",
+    "Niryaana Shoola child periods stay omitted by the 2026-10-23 decision.",
+    "Annual Tithi, Yoga, and Nakshatra headings are outside this pass."
+  ],
+  "within_tolerance": [
+    {
+      "system": "tithi-natal-forward",
+      "chart": 0,
+      "minutes": 0.002
+    },
+    {
+      "system": "tithi-natal-forward",
+      "chart": 1,
+      "minutes": 0.001
+    },
+    {
+      "system": "tithi-natal-forward",
+      "chart": 2,
+      "minutes": 0.001
+    },
+    {
+      "system": "tithi-natal-forward",
+      "chart": 3,
+      "minutes": 0.003
+    },
+    {
+      "system": "tithi-natal-forward",
+      "chart": 4,
+      "minutes": 0.0
+    },
+    {
+      "system": "tithi-natal-forward",
+      "chart": 5,
+      "minutes": 0.002
+    },
+    {
+      "system": "tithi-natal-forward",
+      "chart": 6,
+      "minutes": 0.001
+    },
+    {
+      "system": "tithi-natal-forward",
+      "chart": 7,
+      "minutes": 0.002
+    },
+    {
+      "system": "tithi-natal-forward",
+      "chart": 8,
+      "minutes": 0.002
+    },
+    {
+      "system": "tithi-natal-forward",
+      "chart": 9,
+      "minutes": 0.003
+    }
+  ],
+  "systems": {
+    "tithi-natal-forward": {
+      "status": "一致",
+      "heading_en": "Natal Tithi Ashtottari forward",
+      "heading_zh": "本命 Tithi Ashtottari 顺行",
+      "match": "exact"
+    },
+    "tithi-natal-reverse": {
+      "status": "无此方法",
+      "heading_en": "Natal Tithi Ashtottari reverse",
+      "heading_zh": "本命 Tithi Ashtottari 逆行",
+      "match": "exact"
+    },
+    "yoga-natal": {
+      "status": "不一致",
+      "heading_en": "Natal Yoga Vimshottari",
+      "heading_zh": "本命 Yoga Vimshottari",
+      "match": "exact",
+      "category": "子运划分",
+      "category_en": "sub-period division",
+      "example": "chart 2 third level under Mercury does not line up"
+    },
+    "buddhi-gati": {
+      "status": "不一致",
+      "heading_en": "Buddhi Gati",
+      "heading_zh": "Buddhi Gati",
+      "match": "exact",
+      "category": "起点",
+      "category_en": "start",
+      "example": "chart 0 period 1 native Sun vs PyJHora Mercury"
+    },
+    "kaala": {
+      "status": "不一致",
+      "heading_en": "Kaala",
+      "heading_zh": "Kaala",
+      "match": "exact",
+      "category": "年数",
+      "category_en": "year count",
+      "example": "chart 0 year count differs at the first compared period of Sun"
+    },
+    "sudasa-birth": {
+      "status": "不一致",
+      "heading_en": "Sudasa birth cycle",
+      "heading_zh": "Sudasa 出生周期",
+      "match": "exact",
+      "category": "年数",
+      "category_en": "year count",
+      "example": "chart 0 year count differs at the first compared period of Scorpio"
+    },
+    "varnada": {
+      "status": "不一致",
+      "heading_en": "Varnada",
+      "heading_zh": "Varnada",
+      "match": "prefix",
+      "category": "起点",
+      "category_en": "start",
+      "example": "chart 0 period 1 native Aries vs PyJHora Capricorn"
+    },
+    "karana-julene": {
+      "status": "不一致",
+      "heading_en": "Julene lords",
+      "heading_zh": "Julene 主星",
+      "match": "prefix",
+      "category": "年数",
+      "category_en": "year count",
+      "example": "chart 0 year count differs at the first compared period of Mars"
+    },
+    "karana-pvr": {
+      "status": "不一致",
+      "heading_en": "PVR quadrant lords",
+      "heading_zh": "PVR 象限主星",
+      "match": "prefix",
+      "category": "年数",
+      "category_en": "year count",
+      "example": "chart 0 year count differs at the first compared period of Mars"
+    },
+    "karana-pvr-tithi-year": {
+      "status": "不一致",
+      "heading_en": "PVR 360 tithi year",
+      "heading_zh": "PVR 360 太阴月年",
+      "match": "prefix",
+      "category": "年数",
+      "category_en": "year count",
+      "example": "chart 0 year count differs at the first compared period of Mars"
+    },
+    "sthira": {
+      "status": "不一致",
+      "heading_en": "Sthira",
+      "heading_zh": "Sthira",
+      "match": "exact",
+      "category": "起点",
+      "category_en": "start",
+      "example": "chart 1 period 1 native Capricorn vs PyJHora Cancer"
+    },
+    "drig": {
+      "status": "不一致",
+      "heading_en": "Drig",
+      "heading_zh": "Drig",
+      "match": "exact",
+      "category": "起点",
+      "category_en": "start",
+      "example": "chart 1 period 10 native Leo vs PyJHora Aquarius"
+    },
+    "shoola": {
+      "status": "不一致",
+      "heading_en": "Shoola",
+      "heading_zh": "Shoola",
+      "match": "exact",
+      "category": "起点",
+      "category_en": "start",
+      "example": "chart 1 period 1 native Sagittarius vs PyJHora Gemini"
+    },
+    "navamsha": {
+      "status": "不一致",
+      "heading_en": "Navamsha",
+      "heading_zh": "Navamsha",
+      "match": "exact",
+      "category": "起点",
+      "category_en": "start",
+      "example": "chart 0 period 1 native Capricorn vs PyJHora Aquarius"
+    },
+    "kalachakra": {
+      "status": "不一致",
+      "heading_en": "Kalachakra",
+      "heading_zh": "Kalachakra",
+      "match": "exact",
+      "category": "起点",
+      "category_en": "start",
+      "example": "chart 0 period 1 native Taurus vs PyJHora Gemini"
+    }
+  }
 }