Astrologer ruling 2026-11-04 on #166, product decisions the same day (Q9
display only, later; Q12 record, do not switch).
- Q4 (BUG-1590): Gemini Saturn (8, 9) and Virgo Saturn (5, 6) are mixed
(neutral), not pure benefics by trine priority; the astrologer's table for
the eight ambiguous cells rides along as ambiguous_cell_notes. Other
lordships are kept.
- Q10 (BUG-1591): Chara Dasha with both Scorpio / Aquarius lords in the sign
is fixed at 12 years (Ketu exalted in Scorpio gave 13).
- Q11 (BUG-1592): legacy Narayana counts only the nine grahas as occupants.
- Q8 (BUG-1593): Narayana period reports the adjustment that took effect
(Mercury in Virgo: 12, +0, not "12 + 1" capped silently).
- Q15 (BUG-1594): upagrahas carry both raw Saturn-part points and name the
mapping (PyJHora-compatible Gulika = start, Maandi = midpoint; PVR 4.3 is the
reverse and is listed, never claimed).
- Q12 / Q13 (BUG-1595): every day/night window, Shadbala and the birth
Panchanga record their sunrise convention and hora method. No value changes.
- Q5 (BUG-1596): "Gajakesari Yoga" is PVR's strict definition (benefic
association, not debilitated, combust or in a natural enemy's sign); the
strong-Jupiter variant and the bare Moon-Jupiter kendra relation are
separate rules outside the card's closed list. New sandbox helpers combust()
and in_natural_enemy_sign().
- Q6 (BUG-1597): Matrunasa split into Raman 198 (named Parashari aspects,
nodes for conjunction / hemming only) and Raman 199 (same parents-card row
via canonical_mapping); each hit names its trigger; "high confidence" and
mother's-health effects removed. Custom rules may set `triggers`.
- Q31 (BUG-1598): calc_varga names the D3 / D24 / D30 / D60 method; D3 / D24 /
D60 of varga.py and divisional_charts_extended agree on every 0.1 deg.
- Q29: the 7-karaka note says PiK does not apply in that scheme.
tests/test_astrologer_rulings_166_batch2.py (25 tests). Rectification
identity and re-freeze follow.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01DbBXoyn7Hj3LCW3BUs5bZ8
Astrologer ruling 2026-11-04 on #166; product decision the same day (Moon
option C, rulings implemented as given). The default is a named BPHS version;
the pre-#166 precise Sthana / Drik is kept byte-for-byte as variant
"raman_gbb" (Raman, Graha and Bhava Balas Ex. 13 / 55 still pass on it).
- Q3 (BUG-1581): the Moon's own Paksha is P on both sides (Sanskrit 27.11 lists
indu), Chesta = Paksha, total 2P. Drik still classifies a waning Moon as a
malefic (Q26), classify_drik_planets unchanged for the Moon.
- Q2 (BUG-1582): the Sun's Ayana is not doubled; Chesta = base Ayana; A + A.
On the VP Jain fixture Kala + Chesta = 46.73 + 35.07 = published 81.80 + 0.
- Q18 (BUG-1583, BUG-1575): Moolatrikona Moon Taurus from 3 deg, Mercury Virgo
from 15 deg, in shadbala.py and jyotish_engine.MOOLATRIKONA.
- Q16 / Q20 (BUG-1584): Saptavargaja 45/30/20/15/10/4/2, compound relation from D1.
- Q25 (BUG-1585): Mercury is a natural malefic with any natural malefic in its
sign (nodes not counted, recorded as an implementation choice).
- Q24 (BUG-1586): BPHS 26.9-12 piecewise special aspects replace the general
segment for Saturn, Mars and Jupiter; a single aspect stays within 0-60.
- Q21 (BUG-1587): Kendradi Bala by whole sign from the Lagna sign.
- Q27 (BUG-1588): jaimini.calc_arudha_pada_for_house takes the 10th from the
first-count pada (pada in the 7th -> 4th from the house), as special_lagnas did.
- Q30 (BUG-1589): D30 degree inside the sign is proportional within the
unequal span in varga.py; divisional_charts_extended uses exact 30/7.
- method_variants names every convention. Q22 edges and the Q24 60 cap are
locked in tests/test_astrologer_rulings_166.py (42 tests).
Raman / PyJHora comparison tests now run on "raman_gbb"; the VP Jain report
labels the new convention rows; chart-insight-golden.json's planets-only
Shadbala section regenerated from /api/shadbala. Rectification identity,
golden and re-freeze follow in separate commits.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01DbBXoyn7Hj3LCW3BUs5bZ8
Product decision 2026-11-04: the calculation follows the sources even though
rectification scores move.
- scripts/varga.py: even-sign Trimsamsa 12-20 Pisces, 20-25 Capricorn,
25-30 Scorpio (was Capricorn / Scorpio / Pisces). KNOWN DEFECT comment
removed; the strict xfail in tests/test_varga_bphs_starts_audit_g.py is now
an ordinary test and the 0.1-degree BPHS sweep covers varga.py on all signs.
- scripts/functional_benefics.py: ROLE_OVERRIDES adds Venus = malefic for
Aries (BPHS 34.20) and Scorpio (34.35); profile doc lists both cells.
Both feed rectification scoring; the scoring-13 identity bump, memoization
golden v6 and the ERR-110 re-freeze follow in the next commits.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01DbBXoyeZrYn6ryNcSe5Y2Y
Data audit wave 2 (G): 19 fixed charts, Raman and Lahiri, mean nodes, both
engines set explicitly. Against PyJHora method 1 ("traditional Parasara") on
the same longitudes, varga.py matched D16/D20 26%, D27 25%, D45 14%, and
divisional_charts_extended (chart page, consultation varga spectrum) matched
D16/D20 7%, D27 14%, D40/D45 25%, D30 50%. jyotishganit agrees with PyJHora
190/190 on every one of these, and both follow BPHS ch. 6.
- varga.varga_map: D16/D45 movable/fixed/dual from Aries/Leo/Sagittarius,
D20 from Aries/Sagittarius/Leo, D27 fiery/earthy/airy/watery from
Aries/Cancer/Libra/Capricorn (were odd/even starts). BUG-1560.
- divisional_charts_extended: D16/D20/D27/D40/D45 signs now read varga_map;
D30 uses the BPHS signs (odd 25-30 Libra; even Taurus, Virgo, Pisces,
Capricorn, Scorpio). BUG-1561.
- trimshamsa_d30: even-sign table copied from jyotishganit swapped Jupiter
and Saturn; now 12-20 Pisces, 20-25 Capricorn, 25-30 Scorpio. BUG-1562.
- shodasavarga guide: D4/D10/D24/D27/D30/D40 rule text corrected.
Held back: varga.py even-sign D30 has the same defect, but it feeds
rectification scoring. Fixing it moved the sealed holdout (top-1 0.50 to
0.45) and 166/900 offset trials and turned the memoization goldens red,
which per BUG-1260/1275 means a scoring-13 identity: a product decision.
It carries a KNOWN DEFECT comment and a strict xfail test.
After: same-longitude agreement with PyJHora is 190/190 for D3-D60 in
divisional_charts_extended and for every varga.py chart except D30.
D9/D10/D12, karakas and Arudha are unchanged; the evidence card check
(27 cards, 765 fields) shows 0 differences before and after.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01DbBXoyeZrYn6ryNcSe5Y2Y
The production D60 branch added one sign to 1-based even signs, with no
source, while the repository's own guide and the vedastro mapping count
from the sign itself. PyJHora agrees with the latter: 33/77 recorded times
before, 77/77 after.
- scripts/varga.py: D60 is (si+pi)%12 for odd and even signs; other
mappings and the vedastro mode are untouched.
- tests/test_d60_varga_mapping.py: 12 signs x 60 parts against
PyJHora, plus the even-sign first part.
- scripts/research/d60_two_way_run.py: the G1 reconciliation that found
this, now in the repository with a test; G1 passes 77/77.
- scripts/varga.py is part of the extended frozen identity, so the sealed
holdout and the reported-offset sweep were re-frozen per ERR-110. All
20 and 900 trials match the upstream_sync9b records on every field and
the metrics and summary are unchanged.
Co-Authored-By: Grok (agent loop)
Upstream 50847e57, ported semantically:
- Sarpa Drekkana now accepts the five classical ranges (Cancer 2/3,
Scorpio 1/2, Pisces 3) and partitions on the raw longitude instead of
the rounded display degrees.
- The 22nd Drekkana is the eighth house of D3 (+7), not +21 zodiacal
ten-degree divisions.
scripts/varga.py is part of the extended frozen identity, so the sealed
holdout and the reported-offset sweep were re-frozen under ERR-110:
20/20 sealed trials and 900/900 sweep trials match the sync8 records on
every compared field, and the metrics, summary and widening geometry are
unchanged.
Tests: the upstream varga/ sarpa files are added under
tests/test_upstream_sync9b_*.py; the stale +21 assertion and the sarpa
definition string are updated with the original/new/reason columns in
PROGRESS.
Co-Authored-By: Grok (agent loop)
Three-way-merge calculation modules and pl9-export into the product fork while keeping commercial API routes, Raman ayanamsa, and the consultation contract as a keypath superset.
Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com>
ClaudeandClaude Opus 5.5