#!/usr/bin/env python3 """Jev intent research v2: previous-turn state variants. Offline by default for the report. Source B text stays in the gitignored cache. Committed rows keep gold and model output only. """ from __future__ import annotations import argparse import json import sys from pathlib import Path from typing import Any, Mapping, Sequence ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[2] if str(ROOT) not in sys.path: sys.path.insert(0, str(ROOT)) from scripts.research.jev_intent_probe import ( # noqa: E402 CACHE_DIR, cache_key, confusion_counts, layer_metrics, load_cache, load_jsonl, self_consistency, strip_confidence, ) from scripts.research.jev_intent_questions import ( # noqa: E402 JEV_MODEL, previous_turn_payload, ) from scripts.research.jev_intent_source_b_v2 import OUTPUT_PATH, from_legacy # noqa: E402 REPORT_JSON = ROOT / "docs" / "research" / "jev_intent_2026_09_27.json" REPORT_MD = ROOT / "docs" / "research" / "jev_intent_2026_09_27.md" SAMPLES_DIR = ROOT / "scripts" / "research" / "jev_intent_samples" MIN_WITH_PREVIOUS = 100 PUBLISHED_C_INTENT = {"choice": 0.990, "collect": 0.922, "none": 0.960} PRED_KEEP = ( "ok", "unavailable", "model", "intent", "answer_class", "has_new_dated_event", "confidence", "raw", "input_tokens", "output_tokens", "elapsed_ms", "continued", "continues_previous_turn", "variant", "error", ) def pct(value: float | None) -> str: if value is None: return "—" return f"{value:.1%}" def public_pred(pred: Mapping[str, Any] | None) -> dict[str, Any] | None: if not pred: return None return {key: pred.get(key) for key in PRED_KEEP if key in pred} def has_previous(row: Mapping[str, Any]) -> bool: return previous_turn_payload(row) is not None def unclear_to_focus(rows: Sequence[Mapping[str, Any]], pred_key: str) -> int: count = 0 for row in rows: if row.get("layer") != "none": continue if (row.get("gold") or {}).get("intent") != "unclear": continue if (row.get(pred_key) or {}).get("intent") == "answer_current_focus": count += 1 return count def strip_block(block: dict[str, Any] | None) -> dict[str, Any] | None: """Flash has no confidence. Leave those rates empty instead of printing 0%.""" if not block: return None out = dict(block) out["all"] = strip_confidence(block.get("all")) out["by_layer"] = { layer: strip_confidence(metrics) if metrics else None for layer, metrics in (block.get("by_layer") or {}).items() } out["with_previous"] = strip_confidence(block.get("with_previous")) out["without_previous"] = strip_confidence(block.get("without_previous")) return out def pack_metrics(rows: Sequence[Mapping[str, Any]], pred_key: str) -> dict[str, Any] | None: usable = [row for row in rows if row.get(pred_key)] if not usable: return None by_layer = {} for layer in ("choice", "collect", "none"): subset = [row for row in usable if row.get("layer") == layer] by_layer[layer] = layer_metrics(subset, pred_key=pred_key) if subset else None with_prev = [row for row in usable if row.get("has_previous_turn")] without_prev = [row for row in usable if not row.get("has_previous_turn")] return { "all": layer_metrics(usable, pred_key=pred_key), "by_layer": by_layer, "with_previous": layer_metrics(with_prev, pred_key=pred_key) if with_prev else None, "without_previous": layer_metrics(without_prev, pred_key=pred_key) if without_prev else None, "none_unclear_to_focus": unclear_to_focus(usable, pred_key), "self_consistency": None, } def attach_legacy_preds(samples: Sequence[dict[str, Any]], cache: Mapping[str, Any], mapping: Mapping[str, str]) -> dict[str, int]: missing = {dest: 0 for dest in mapping} for sample in samples: for dest, legacy in mapping.items(): key = cache_key(legacy, sample) if key in cache: pred = dict(cache[key]) pred["variant"] = "v0" sample[dest] = pred else: missing[dest] += 1 return missing def public_rows(samples: Sequence[Mapping[str, Any]], pred_keys: Sequence[str]) -> list[dict[str, Any]]: rows = [] for sample in samples: row = { "id": sample.get("id"), "source": sample.get("source"), "layer": sample.get("layer"), "gold": sample.get("gold"), "gold_source": sample.get("gold_source"), "has_previous_turn": bool(sample.get("has_previous_turn")), "previous_turn_source": sample.get("previous_turn_source"), } for key in pred_keys: pred = public_pred(sample.get(key) if isinstance(sample.get(key), dict) else None) if pred: row[key] = pred rows.append(row) return rows def decide(meta: Mapping[str, Any], metrics: Mapping[str, Any]) -> dict[str, str]: blocked: list[str] = [] if meta.get("n_with_previous", 0) < MIN_WITH_PREVIOUS: blocked.append(f"n_有上一轮 {meta.get('n_with_previous', 0)} < {MIN_WITH_PREVIOUS}") if not metrics.get("jev_v1"): blocked.append("V1 没有预测") if not metrics.get("jev_v2_chain"): blocked.append("V2 链式没有预测") if not metrics.get("jev_v2_gold"): blocked.append("V2 gold 上界没有预测") if not metrics.get("flash_v1"): blocked.append("Flash+V1 没有预测") if not metrics.get("flash_v0"): blocked.append("Flash V0 没有预测") represent = metrics.get("representativeness") or {} if represent.get("fail"): blocked.append("来源 B 与来源 C 同层 intent 差 > 10pp") if blocked: return { "verdict": "缺数据", "blocked": ";".join(blocked), "reason": "上一轮变量没有测全,不能判过门。已有的 V0 数字只作对照,不代替 V1/V2。", } v0_none = ((metrics.get("jev_v0") or {}).get("by_layer") or {}).get("none") or {} v2_none = ((metrics.get("jev_v2_chain") or {}).get("by_layer") or {}).get("none") or {} v0_high = v0_none.get("high_conf_error_rate") v2_high = v2_none.get("high_conf_error_rate") if v0_high is None or v2_high is None: return {"verdict": "blocked", "blocked": "无焦点层高置信错误写不出", "reason": "V2 相对 V0 的无焦点层比较缺数字。"} jev = (metrics.get("jev_v2_chain") or {}).get("all") or {} flash = (metrics.get("flash_v0") or {}).get("all") or {} high = jev.get("high_conf_error_rate") recall = jev.get("low_conf_recall") jev_intent = jev.get("intent_acc") flash_intent = flash.get("intent_acc") missing = [ name for name, value in ( ("高置信错误", high), ("低置信召回", recall), ("V2 intent", jev_intent), ("Flash V0 intent", flash_intent), ) if value is None ] if missing: return {"verdict": "blocked", "blocked": "、".join(missing), "reason": "门槛里有写不出的数字。"} gates = [] if high > 0.03: gates.append(f"高置信错误 {high:.1%} > 3%") if recall < 0.60: gates.append(f"低置信召回 {recall:.1%} < 60%") if jev_intent < flash_intent - 0.03: gates.append(f"intent {jev_intent:.1%} < 现行 {flash_intent:.1%} − 3pp") if v2_high >= v0_high: gates.append(f"无焦点层高置信错误 V2 {v2_high:.1%} 没有低于 V0 {v0_high:.1%}") if gates: return {"verdict": "未过门", "blocked": "", "reason": ";".join(gates)} return { "verdict": "过门", "blocked": "", "reason": "三项门槛都过,且 V2 无焦点层高置信错误低于 V0。", } def representativeness(source_b: Sequence[Mapping[str, Any]], source_c: Sequence[Mapping[str, Any]]) -> dict[str, Any]: layers = {} fail = False for layer in ("choice", "collect", "none"): b_rows = [row for row in source_b if row.get("layer") == layer and row.get("jev_v0_1")] c_rows = [row for row in source_c if row.get("layer") == layer and row.get("jev_v0_1")] if not b_rows or not c_rows: layers[layer] = {"n_b": len(b_rows), "n_c": len(c_rows), "delta": None} continue b_acc = layer_metrics(b_rows, pred_key="jev_v0_1")["intent_acc"] c_acc = layer_metrics(c_rows, pred_key="jev_v0_1")["intent_acc"] delta = abs(b_acc - c_acc) fail = fail or delta > 0.10 published = PUBLISHED_C_INTENT[layer] layers[layer] = { "n_b": len(b_rows), "n_c": len(c_rows), "source_b_intent": b_acc, "source_c_intent": c_acc, "delta": delta, "published_c_intent": published, "published_delta_pp": (c_acc - published) * 100, } return {"fail": fail, "by_layer": layers} def build_from_samples(source_b: Sequence[dict[str, Any]], source_c: Sequence[dict[str, Any]]) -> dict[str, Any]: for row in list(source_b) + list(source_c): if "previous_turn" in row: row["has_previous_turn"] = has_previous(row) else: row["has_previous_turn"] = bool(row.get("has_previous_turn")) pred_keys = ("jev_v0_1", "jev_v0_2", "flash_v0") b_metrics = { "jev_v0": pack_metrics(source_b, "jev_v0_1"), "flash_v0": strip_block(pack_metrics(source_b, "flash_v0")), "jev_v1": pack_metrics(source_b, "jev_v1_1"), "jev_v2_chain": pack_metrics(source_b, "jev_v2_chain_1"), "jev_v2_gold": pack_metrics(source_b, "jev_v2_gold_1"), "flash_v1": strip_block(pack_metrics(source_b, "flash_v1")), } if b_metrics["jev_v0"]: b_metrics["jev_v0"]["self_consistency"] = self_consistency(source_b, "jev_v0_1", "jev_v0_2") none_b = [row for row in source_b if row.get("layer") == "none"] meta = { "model": JEV_MODEL, "sdk": "typesafe-sdk 0.7.0", "source_b_n": len(source_b), "n_with_previous": sum(1 for row in source_b if row.get("has_previous_turn")), "n_without_previous": sum(1 for row in source_b if not row.get("has_previous_turn")), "layers": { layer: sum(1 for row in source_b if row.get("layer") == layer) for layer in ("choice", "collect", "none") }, "gold_source": {}, "source_c_n": len(source_c), "previous_decision_note": "链式与 gold 上界都未跑。09-19 文件没有 turn_id / case_id,本机没有 staging 库。", } gold_counts: dict[str, int] = {} for row in source_b: source = str(row.get("gold_source") or "unknown") gold_counts[source] = gold_counts.get(source, 0) + 1 meta["gold_source"] = gold_counts metrics = { **b_metrics, "source_c_v0": pack_metrics(source_c, "jev_v0_1"), "representativeness": representativeness(source_b, source_c), "source_b_none_confusion": { "jev_v0": confusion_counts(none_b, "jev_v0_1"), "flash_v0": confusion_counts(none_b, "flash_v0"), } if none_b else {}, } if metrics["source_c_v0"]: metrics["source_c_v0"]["self_consistency"] = self_consistency(source_c, "jev_v0_1", "jev_v0_2") conclusion = decide(meta, metrics) return { "meta": meta, "metrics": metrics, "conclusion": conclusion, "rows": public_rows(list(source_b) + list(source_c), pred_keys + ( "jev_v1_1", "jev_v1_2", "jev_v2_chain_1", "jev_v2_chain_2", "jev_v2_gold_1", "jev_v2_gold_2", "flash_v1", )), } def load_samples() -> tuple[list[dict[str, Any]], list[dict[str, Any]], dict[str, int]]: if OUTPUT_PATH.is_file(): source_b = load_jsonl(OUTPUT_PATH) else: source_b = from_legacy(load_jsonl(CACHE_DIR / "source_b.jsonl")) source_b = [row for row in source_b if isinstance(row.get("gold"), dict) and row["gold"].get("intent")] source_c = load_jsonl(SAMPLES_DIR / "simulated.jsonl") cache = load_cache() missing = {} missing.update(attach_legacy_preds(source_b, cache, { "jev_v0_1": "jev_1", "jev_v0_2": "jev_2", "flash_v0": "current_1", })) missing.update(attach_legacy_preds(source_c, cache, { "jev_v0_1": "jev_1", "jev_v0_2": "jev_2", })) return source_b, source_c, missing def recompute_from_rows(rows: Sequence[Mapping[str, Any]]) -> dict[str, Any]: source_b = [dict(row) for row in rows if row.get("source") == "B"] source_c = [dict(row) for row in rows if row.get("source") == "C"] return build_from_samples(source_b, source_c) def metric_line(title: str, block: Mapping[str, Any] | None) -> str: if not block or not block.get("all"): return f"| {title} | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |" all_m = block["all"] none_high = ((block.get("by_layer") or {}).get("none") or {}).get("high_conf_error_rate") return ( f"| {title} | {all_m['n']} | {pct(all_m['intent_acc'])} | {pct(all_m['answer_class_acc'])} | " f"{pct(all_m['dated_acc'])} | {pct(all_m['high_conf_error_rate'])} | {pct(all_m['low_conf_recall'])} | " f"{block.get('none_unclear_to_focus')} / 无焦点高置信错误 {pct(none_high)} |" ) def write_markdown(report: Mapping[str, Any]) -> None: meta = report["meta"] metrics = report["metrics"] conclusion = report["conclusion"] layers = meta.get("layers") or {} gold = meta.get("gold_source") or {} represent = metrics.get("representativeness") or {} lines = [ "# TypeSafe Jev 意图分类 · 上一轮 state 对照(2026-09-27)", "", f"- 任务:`docs/tasks/TASK-rectification-jev-intent-classifier-research-v2-20260927.md`", f"- 基线:`origin/staging` @ `710c848b`", f"- 模型:`{meta.get('model')}`;SDK `{meta.get('sdk')}`", f"- 结论:**{conclusion.get('verdict')}**。{conclusion.get('reason')}", "", "## 样本", "", f"- 来源 B:{meta.get('source_b_n')} 条。有上一轮 {meta.get('n_with_previous')},无上一轮 {meta.get('n_without_previous')}。", f"- 层:点选 {layers.get('choice', 0)} / 采集 {layers.get('collect', 0)} / 无焦点 {layers.get('none', 0)}。", f"- gold 来源:{json.dumps(gold, ensure_ascii=False)}。", f"- {meta.get('previous_decision_note')}", "", "## 来源 B", "", "| 变体 | n | intent | answer_class | dated | 高置信错误 | 低置信召回 | 无焦点 unclear→answer |", "| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | --- |", metric_line("Jev V0(09-19 缓存)", metrics.get("jev_v0")), metric_line("Flash V0(09-19 缓存,生产提示)", metrics.get("flash_v0")), metric_line("Jev V1", metrics.get("jev_v1")), metric_line("Jev V2 链式", metrics.get("jev_v2_chain")), metric_line("Jev V2 gold 上界", metrics.get("jev_v2_gold")), metric_line("Flash + V1", metrics.get("flash_v1")), "", f"Jev V0 自洽率:{pct((metrics.get('jev_v0') or {}).get('self_consistency'))}。", "", "## 来源 C 回归锚(只 V0)", "", ] c_block = metrics.get("source_c_v0") or {} for layer in ("choice", "collect", "none"): cell = (represent.get("by_layer") or {}).get(layer) or {} published = cell.get("published_c_intent") got = cell.get("source_c_intent") delta = cell.get("published_delta_pp") lines.append( f"- {layer}:重算 {pct(got)},09-19 公布 {pct(published)},差 {delta if delta is None else round(delta, 2)} pp(n={cell.get('n_c')})。" ) lines += [ f"- 来源 C 自洽率:{pct(c_block.get('self_consistency'))}。", "", "## 无焦点层混淆(来源 B,V0)", "", "计数来自报告 JSON,不含原文。", "", ] confusion = (metrics.get("source_b_none_confusion") or {}).get("jev_v0") or {} labels = confusion.get("labels") or [] counts = confusion.get("counts") or {} if labels: lines.append("| gold \\ pred | " + " | ".join(labels) + " |") lines.append("| --- | " + " | ".join("---:" for _ in labels) + " |") for gold in labels: cells = [str((counts.get(gold) or {}).get(pred, 0)) for pred in labels] lines.append(f"| {gold} | " + " | ".join(cells) + " |") lines += [ "", "## 写不出的项", "", conclusion.get("blocked") or "无", "", "V1、V2、Flash+V1 要等 staging 库抽出带 `case_id` 的上一轮,并且本机有 `DEEPSEEK_API_KEY` 之后才能补。门槛不放宽。", "", ] REPORT_MD.write_text("\n".join(lines) + "\n", encoding="utf-8") def main(argv: Sequence[str] | None = None) -> int: parser = argparse.ArgumentParser() parser.add_argument("--offline", action="store_true") parser.add_argument("--from-report", action="store_true", help="recompute tables from the committed JSON rows") args = parser.parse_args(argv) if args.from_report: if not REPORT_JSON.is_file(): print("report json missing", file=sys.stderr) return 2 payload = json.loads(REPORT_JSON.read_text(encoding="utf-8")) report = recompute_from_rows(payload.get("rows") or []) report["meta"]["recomputed_from"] = "report_rows" write_markdown(report) print(json.dumps({ "verdict": report["conclusion"]["verdict"], "source_b_intent": ((report["metrics"].get("jev_v0") or {}).get("all") or {}).get("intent_acc"), "n": report["meta"]["source_b_n"], "n_with_previous": report["meta"]["n_with_previous"], }, ensure_ascii=False)) return 0 source_b, source_c, missing = load_samples() report = build_from_samples(source_b, source_c) report["meta"]["legacy_cache_missing"] = missing report["meta"]["offline"] = True REPORT_JSON.write_text(json.dumps(report, ensure_ascii=False, indent=2), encoding="utf-8") write_markdown(report) print(json.dumps({ "verdict": report["conclusion"]["verdict"], "source_b_n": report["meta"]["source_b_n"], "n_with_previous": report["meta"]["n_with_previous"], "missing": missing, "json": str(REPORT_JSON), }, ensure_ascii=False)) return 0 if __name__ == "__main__": raise SystemExit(main())