Files
Jyotisha/references/upstream/evidence_thresholds.md
T
Jesse_Chen 30ef6afea7
Independent Staging Quality Gate / validate (push) Has been cancelled
Independent Staging Quality Gate / publish (push) Has been cancelled
docs(rectification): archive upstream playbook and add stop-rule task
The upstream interview playbook and evidence thresholds resolve task 0.
Upstream stops and reports when evidence is thin — fewer than three dated
events, fewer than two domains, or a tie — while this repo treats the same
kind of thresholds as a confirmation gate and keeps asking when they are
not met. Its label ladder has no confirmed rung at all, and every contract
test asserts candidate_range_not_birth_time_truth.

Task 1 capped the interview by round count, which is half of it. Task 6
adds the evidence-state stop rules, reframes exhausted as a normal
delivery, adopts the upstream label ladder and closing wording, and keeps
the 4/3 confirmation gate separate from the 3/2 delivery floor.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_0155nFCgCHtoA7jhSDGmZmMu
2026-08-31 02:27:32 +00:00

2.0 KiB

Evidence Thresholds

Labels

  • blocked: required input, route, or event evidence is missing.
  • user_history_verification_required: dates are too sparse or imprecise.
  • parameter_sensitive: small changes in the candidate grid materially alter the lead.
  • manual_pattern_consensus: standalone conversation evidence points to one interval, but no external calculator/audit was executed.
  • single_adapter_support: one user-supplied adapter supports the leading interval.
  • multi_adapter_consensus: multiple executed adapters support the same interval; this is still not birth-time truth.

Standalone Cap

In standalone_core, the highest allowed label is manual_pattern_consensus. Never label 高置信候选 unless the current user actually provided and executed additional audit adapters.

Minimum Standalone Gate

To move beyond blocked, require all of the following:

  • one valid route: range, block, or unknown
  • at least three dated events
  • at least two domains
  • no unresolved tie for first place
  • the explicit boundary 不等于唯一真实出生分钟

Use medium only when there are at least five dated events across at least two domains and the lead interval is clearly ahead. Use low when the evidence points somewhere but remains shallow or fragile.

Optional Enhanced Gate

Use 高置信候选 only when all are visible and actually executed in the current user's environment:

  • at least five dated events across at least two domains
  • a clear leading interval without a material tie
  • adapter status table with raw-result references
  • if used, separate visibility for Vimshottari + Narayana
  • if used, separate visibility for Functional Benefic/Malefic, relevant vargas, MEVG, Real Case Calibration, and holdout
  • no decisive conflict from any executed adapter

Any blocked, conflicting, or missing raw-evidence item caps the output at manual_pattern_consensus, medium, low, parameter_sensitive, or blocked as appropriate. 高置信候选 不等于唯一真实出生分钟.