Audit dignity guardrail v1 boundary

2026-06-28 14:20:21 +08:00
parent cf192d1a1e
commit 7390ff1b6f
2 changed files with 67 additions and 0 deletions
@@ -36,3 +36,9 @@ This file is the small index for the current engineering fronts that still drive

 - `/Users/wuyongnaren/Documents/印度占星/scripts/vedastro_service_adapter.py`
 - follow only after the Jaimini marriage bridge v1 regression loop is closed
+
+## Dignity / Role Guardrails
+
+- `/Users/wuyongnaren/Documents/印度占星/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-06-28-dignity-guardrail-v1-design.md`
+- `/Users/wuyongnaren/Documents/印度占星/docs/research/dignity_guardrail_v1_boundary_audit_2026_06_28.md`
+- D1-only dignity guardrail is now landed; divisional dignity repair and a separate functional-role guardrail remain open fronts.
@@ -0,0 +1,61 @@
+# Dignity Guardrail v1 Boundary Audit - 2026-06-28
+
+## What Landed
+
+- `dignity_guardrail` has been added to `relationship` and `finance` strict workflows.
+- The guardrail reads only D1 `chart.planets.status`.
+- Only route-relevant planets may affect the guardrail result.
+- Score impact is bounded to a single `-5 | 0 | +5`.
+- The previous whole-chart dignity broadcast has been removed from `_derive_event_judgement`.
+
+## What Did Not Land
+
+- No D9 dignity scoring
+- No D10 dignity scoring
+- No Vimsopaka dignity scoring
+- No `dominant_label` lifting from dignity
+- No merge with Functional Benefic/Malefic logic
+- No multi-planet cumulative dignity scoring
+
+## Verified Boundary
+
+The current implementation now enforces these behaviors:
+
+1. non-relevant planets are ignored for route scoring
+2. mixed relevant `NEECHA_BHANGA` and `GREAT_ENEMY` signals collapse to `conflict`
+3. `conflict` does not directly change event labels
+4. `relationship` and `finance` retain their pre-existing label logic
+5. dignity only modifies:
+   - `event_judgement.score`
+   - `event_judgement.secondary_context`
+   - `confidence_cap` when a conflict is present
+
+## Why This Is Safer Than The Previous State
+
+The previous implementation scanned all natal planets and added or subtracted score directly from chart status strings. That allowed unrelated dignity states to alter relationship or finance verdicts.
+
+The new guardrail restores strict-workflow discipline by making dignity:
+
+- domain-aware
+- bounded
+- auditable
+- non-authoritative
+
+## Known Follow-Ups
+
+1. Repair divisional dignity data-flow separately in `scripts/jyotish_engine.py`
+   - current divisional dignity calculations still need an isolated follow-up review
+2. Build `functional_role_guardrail`
+   - this should consume the already existing Functional Benefic/Malefic layer
+3. Decide later whether `GREAT_FRIEND` should receive context-only semantics
+4. Consider whether a route-specific audit table row should be emitted for dignity guardrail status
+
+## Verification
+
+Executed:
+
+- `python3 -m pytest tests/test_mcp_strict_workflow_relationship.py tests/test_mcp_strict_workflow_finance.py -q`
+
+Result:
+
+- `25 passed`